Demystifying MSEFC Arbitration under the MSMED Act by Delhi High Court

On February 5, 2020, the High Court of Delhi delivered a significant judgment in the matter of M/S Godwin Construction Pvt Ltd & Ors versus Tulip Contractors & Anr, bearing case number W.P.(C) 10573/2019. The Court passed the order to address a fundamental question in commercial litigation regarding the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006. The central legal issue was whether a business entity must be formally registered under the MSMED Act at the exact time a contract is executed and performed to invoke the statutory arbitration mechanism, or if securing registration just before filing a dispute reference is legally sufficient.

Background of the Commercial Dispute

The conflict originated from a business relationship and subsequent contractual disagreements between the petitioners and the first respondent, which pertained to the period between 2010 and 2011. Years after the work was performed, the respondent approached the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Centre to resolve their pending payment disputes. On June 24, 2019, the Facilitation Centre issued an order directing the matter to the Delhi International Arbitration Centre for the initiation of arbitration proceedings under Section 18(3) of the MSMED Act. The petitioners challenged this referral order by filing a writ petition before the High Court.

Jurisdictional Challenges Raised by the Petitioner

The petitioners argued that the Facilitation Centre lacked the jurisdictional authority to refer the matter to arbitration. They highlighted that the respondent only officially registered under the MSMED Act on November 22, 2017, which was several years after the actual commercial transactions took place. According to the petitioners, a party must be a registered supplier under Section 2(n) read with Section 8 of the MSMED Act during the actual performance of the contract to avail itself of the statutory benefits.
Furthermore, the petitioners pointed out that the respondent had previously filed a company petition for winding up in the Allahabad High Court. That petition was dismissed in November 2017 with an observation that a civil suit was the appropriate remedy. Therefore, the petitioners claimed the current arbitration reference was entirely barred.

Judicial Analysis and Statutory Interpretation

The respondents countered these arguments by relying on established judicial precedents, specifically citing the case of GE T&D India Limited versus Reliable Engineering Projects and Marketing. The High Court carefully examined the statutory framework of Section 18 of the MSMED Act alongside this precedent. The Court noted that an enterprise does not cease to be a micro or small enterprise simply because it lacks formal registration at a specific moment in time. The MSMED Act is a beneficial piece of legislation designed to protect small businesses and ensure timely payments. Previous judgments firmly established that a supplier operating prior to formal registration can still seek registration later and utilize the dispute resolution provisions of the Act.
The High Court observed that the crucial requirement for invoking Section 18 of the MSMED Act is that the micro or small enterprise must hold a valid registration on the date the reference is made to the Facilitation Centre. As long as this specific condition is satisfied, the reference is perfectly maintainable even if the actual supply of goods or rendering of services occurred prior to the formal registration date.
Furthermore, the Court reviewed the Udyog Aadhar Registration Certificate of the respondent. This document clearly demonstrated that the enterprise had been carrying out its operations since April 30, 2010. This date preceded the supplies made to the petitioner company, validating their operational status as a small enterprise during the relevant contractual period.

Final Outcome of the Case

The Court also dismissed the argument regarding the previous winding up petition. It clarified that the Allahabad High Court merely ruled on the maintainability of the winding up process and did not restrict the respondent from seeking a valid statutory reference under the MSMED Act. Ultimately, the Court passed the order dismissing the writ petition, thereby upholding the jurisdiction of the Facilitation Centre to refer the commercial dispute to arbitration.

Read the Judgment here.

Categories

Categories

Related Articles

Have questions on this topic or a
related matter?

Our team is available to provide structured, practical guidance.

DISCLAIMER

The Bar Council of India prohibits lawyers and law firms from soliciting work and advertising in any form or manner. By accessing this website, you acknowledge that you are seeking information about Curare Legal, on your own accord without solicitation, advertisement, or inducement from us or our members. This website provides general information for reference purposes only, and we make no promises or guarantees regarding its accuracy, completeness, or reliability. The website’s contents are not intended to constitute legal advice or solicitation and should not be construed as such. By using this website, you agree that the information and materials are for your general information only and do not establish an attorney-client relationship or provide legal advice. All content and materials on this website are the intellectual property of Curare Legal and shall not be used without our express prior written consent.