Understanding Territorial Jurisdiction and Pre-Institution Mediation in Trademark Disputes

On October 27, 2022, the High Court of Delhi delivered a crucial judgment concerning trademark litigation procedures. The case, related to return of a plaint for lack of territorial jurisdiction under Order VII Rule 10 CPC and the mandatory nature of pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act.
The appellant filed a suit seeking a permanent injunction to prevent trademark and copyright infringement, alongside passing off claims. The appellant held registered trademarks for ‘1192’ and ‘JAGMAG 1192’ and claimed the respondent was manufacturing chewing tobacco under the deceptively similar label ‘SIGNAL 1191’. The suit was filed in Delhi. The appellant claimed the respondent was clandestinely selling the infringing goods within the jurisdiction of the Delhi courts and advertising them through interactive websites.
The Commercial Court initially allowed the application of the respondent under Order VII Rule 10 CPC and directed the return of the plaint. The lower court reasoned that the appellant failed to provide concrete evidence of clandestine sales within its jurisdiction. Furthermore, the respondent filed cross-objections. The respondent argued that the plaint should be entirely rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC because the appellant did not exhaust the pre-institution mediation process mandated by Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.
Upon hearing the appeal, the High Court evaluated the legal standards for returning a plaint. The Court noted that an objection regarding territorial jurisdiction must be decided on a demurrer. This legal principle requires the court to accept all statements made in the plaint as entirely true for the purpose of the preliminary application. Relying on established judicial precedents, the High Court reiterated that courts cannot probe into disputed facts at this preliminary stage. The High Court found that the Commercial Court erred by demanding concrete evidence of clandestine sales at the initial stage. Because the appellant clearly pleaded that the respondent was selling goods and operating interactive websites targeting customers within Delhi, the court was legally obligated to accept these averments as correct. Consequently, the High Court ruled that the lower court did indeed have territorial jurisdiction based on the pleadings, making the return of the plaint improper.
The High Court then addressed the cross-objections concerning Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act. The respondent argued that even if a plaintiff seeks urgent interim relief, they must file a formal application seeking exemption from mandatory mediation. The High Court firmly rejected this argument. The Court clarified that Section 12A strictly requires mediation only for suits that do not contemplate urgent interim relief. The statute does not contain any provision requiring a plaintiff to file a formal application for leave to bypass mediation.
The High Court established that the plaintiff is the sole determinant of the pleadings and the relief sought. If a plaint contains prayers for urgent interim relief, the suit is automatically excluded from the rigorous mandate of Section 12A. The commercial court is not required to pre-evaluate whether the urgent relief is justified just to determine if mediation was necessary.
Ultimately, the Court passed the order setting aside the decision of the Commercial Court to return the plaint and dismissed the cross-objections filed by the respondent. This judgment reinforces the principle that plaintiffs must be taken at their word during preliminary jurisdictional challenges and clarifies that seeking urgent relief legally bypasses the need for pre-institution mediation without requiring a separate exemption application.

Read the judgment here.

Categories

Categories

Related Articles

Have questions on this topic or a
related matter?

Our team is available to provide structured, practical guidance.

DISCLAIMER

The Bar Council of India prohibits lawyers and law firms from soliciting work and advertising in any form or manner. By accessing this website, you acknowledge that you are seeking information about Curare Legal, on your own accord without solicitation, advertisement, or inducement from us or our members. This website provides general information for reference purposes only, and we make no promises or guarantees regarding its accuracy, completeness, or reliability. The website’s contents are not intended to constitute legal advice or solicitation and should not be construed as such. By using this website, you agree that the information and materials are for your general information only and do not establish an attorney-client relationship or provide legal advice. All content and materials on this website are the intellectual property of Curare Legal and shall not be used without our express prior written consent.