The intersection of real estate delays and corporate insolvency frequently presents complex legal challenges. On September 30, 2026, the Supreme Court of India resolved a highly significant legal anomaly regarding the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code. The Court passed the order in Civil Appeal Nos. 6797 of 2023, comprehensively addressing whether an Adjudicating Authority possesses the jurisdiction to recall a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process that was initiated through deception.
The litigation originated from a delayed real estate project known as Greenopolis in Gurgaon. The appellant, Orris Infrastructure Private Limited, owned the land, while the Corporate Debtor was tasked with constructing the project. As the Corporate Debtor failed to complete the construction, distressed homebuyers approached the state real estate regulatory authority, which ultimately directed the landowner to assume primary responsibility for the project.
During these regulatory interventions, an entity claiming to be an operational creditor filed a Section 9 Petition to initiate a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process against the Corporate Debtor. The director of the Corporate Debtor quickly admitted the debt, prompting the Adjudicating Authority to admit the petition and impose a moratorium. This sudden moratorium blocked the homebuyers from pursuing their alternative legal remedies.
Upon closer inspection, the Adjudicating Authority discovered that the operational creditor and the Corporate Debtor had acted in active collusion to fraudulently trigger the insolvency proceedings. Despite recognizing this fraud, the Adjudicating Authority ruled that it lacked the statutory power to recall its own admission order. The matter was appealed to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal. The appellate tribunal correctly held that the Adjudicating Authority does have the power to recall fraudulent orders. However, the appellate tribunal took the extreme step of completely setting aside the entire insolvency process.
Various stakeholders, including the landowner and the homebuyers, appealed this complete cancellation to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court had to answer whether the dismissal of a fraudulent Section 9 Petition inevitably demands the termination of the entire insolvency process.
The Court thoroughly analyzed the public law nature of insolvency proceedings. It clarified that invoking the jurisdiction of a tribunal using fabricated facts constitutes a fraud on the public law process. Consequently, the Adjudicating Authority retains the inherent jurisdiction to recall the admission of a Section 9 Petition if the foundational jurisdictional facts were manipulated.
However, the Court highlighted a crucial distinction regarding the nature of insolvency proceedings. While a Section 9 Petition begins as a private dispute between two parties, the admission of the petition transforms the matter into an action in rem. Once the process commences, a multitude of independent creditors and stakeholders join the fold. The proceedings detach from the original applicant and reorient toward the collective resolution of the corporate entity. Therefore, discovering that the initial applicant acted collusively does not mean the entire process must automatically collapse.
The Court ruled that the Adjudicating Authority can oust the fraudulent applicant and penalize the colluding parties, but it still holds the jurisdiction to continue the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process for the benefit of the genuine stakeholders. To ensure stability, the Court passed the order setting aside the appellate tribunal judgment. The Supreme Court restored the insolvency proceedings and directed the Adjudicating Authority to independently evaluate whether to continue the resolution process after hearing the legitimate stakeholders and the Committee of Creditors.
Read the Judgment here.