On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court delivered a landmark ruling in the highly publicized insolvency of Videocon Industries Limited and its group companies. The legal dispute, Civil Appeal No. 894 of 2022 along with several connected appeals, addressed fundamental questions regarding the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process.
The Court passed the order resolving two major controversies: the legality of payments to dissenting financial creditors and the inclusion of foreign subsidiary assets within the insolvency estate.
The first major issue arose from the resolution plan submitted by the Successful Resolution Applicant, Twinstar Technologies Limited. The plan proposed paying dissenting financial creditors primarily through Non Convertible Debentures redeemable over several years. The National Company Law Tribunal initially approved the plan but directed that dissenting creditors be paid in cash upfront. The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal subsequently set aside this approval and remanded the matter back to the Committee of Creditors.
Upon review, the Supreme Court affirmed the appellate tribunal decision. The Court clarified that under Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, payment to dissenting financial creditors must be made strictly in terms of money. Forcing dissenting creditors to accept deferred payment instruments like debentures violates the statutory mandate. Furthermore, the Court emphasized that an adjudicating authority cannot modify a resolution plan to cure such deficiencies. Commercial wisdom belongs exclusively to the Committee of Creditors, meaning a non compliant plan must be remitted back to the committee rather than judicially rewritten.
The Successful Resolution Applicant argued that the Committee of Creditors becomes functus officio after approving a resolution plan and cannot reconsider its decision. The Court firmly rejected this argument. It held that the committee remains in existence throughout the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process. When a statutory appeal reveals that an approved plan violates the law, remitting the plan back to the committee is the only legally sound course of action.
The second facet of the litigation involved appeals by the erstwhile promoter seeking to include foreign oil and gas assets situated in Brazil and Indonesia within the insolvency estate of Videocon Industries Limited. These assets were held through various foreign subsidiary companies.
The Court dismissed these appeals by reinforcing the established corporate law principle that a holding company and its subsidiaries are distinct legal entities. Specifically, the Court noted that the Explanation to Section 18 of the Code expressly excludes the assets of any Indian or foreign subsidiary from the assets of the corporate debtor. The promoter attempted to argue that the corporate veil should be lifted to treat the entire group as a single economic unit. However, the Court ruled that the corporate veil cannot be pierced to override an explicit statutory exclusion. Additionally, the promoter was estopped from making this claim due to his own previous conduct and acquiescence in the insolvency proceedings.
Setting clear guardrails for future insolvency litigation, the Court outlined that the power to remand a resolution plan must be exercised sparingly and solely to ensure legal compliance and maximize asset value. Ultimately, the Court passed the order dismissing all the civil appeals, thereby upholding the sanctity of the statutory exclusions and the paramount commercial wisdom of the Committee of Creditors.
Read the Judgment here.