Supreme Court reverses High Court’s Dismissal for alternative remedy, Rules on GST Liability for Solar Projects

On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court of India delivered a crucial judgment addressing the complexities of the Goods and Services Tax framework and the invocation of writ jurisdiction. The case, identified as Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 23844 of 2025, involved M/s. Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. and the Union of India. This ruling resolves significant ambiguities regarding the classification of Solar Power Generating Systems under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act.

The High Court’s Erroneous Dismissal

The litigation began when the appellant filed a writ petition in the Bombay High Court challenging a tax demand and penalty order totaling over Rs. 53 crores, issued by the Central Goods and Services Tax authorities. The High Court summarily dismissed the writ petition on the sole ground that the appellant had an efficacious alternate appellate remedy available and failed to justify bypassing the mandatory pre-deposit requirement.
The Supreme Court sharply criticized this cursory dismissal. The Court passed the order noting that the availability of an alternate remedy is not a strict, straitjacketed formula that absolutely bars writ jurisdiction. Because the appellant raised highly arguable legal points regarding statutory interpretation that had already been adjudicated by other High Courts, the Supreme Court found the Bombay High Court’s refusal to examine the merits unjustified. Instead of remanding the matter, the Supreme Court chose to decide the substantive legal issues itself.

The Substantive Dispute: Works Contract vs. Composite Supply

The core of the dispute revolved around the GST rate applicable to the supply and installation of Solar Power Generating Systems on an EPC (Engineering Procurement Construction) basis between July 2017 and December 2018. The appellant paid a 5% GST rate, treating the entire transaction as a composite supply of goods under the relevant notifications. However, the Revenue argued that the installation involved civil foundation work, converting the solar system into immovable property. Therefore, the Revenue classified the transaction as a works contract subject to a higher 18% tax rate for the service component.
The Supreme Court heavily relied on the distinction between a composite supply and a works contract. Drawing from prior judgments, including Bharti Airtel Limited, the Court applied several tests—such as the permanency test, functionality test, and marketability test—to determine if an object is immovable property. The Court found that simply attaching a solar panel system to a civil foundation using nuts and bolts for operational stability does not permanently embed it in the earth. Because the solar panels can be dismantled, relocated, and reused without damage, they remain movable goods. Therefore, the transaction was a composite supply of goods, not a works contract.

Prospective Application of Tax Regimes

The Court also addressed a crucial GST Council circular that introduced a 70:30 valuation ratio for goods and services in solar projects. While this new regime took effect on January 1, 2019, the government issued a circular allowing taxpayers the option to apply this ratio retrospectively for the period between July 2017 and December 2018. The Revenue incorrectly interpreted this optional concession as a mandatory directive, demanding tax shortfalls and imposing penalties for willful misstatement under Section 74 of the CGST Act.
The Supreme Court clarified that the 70:30 ratio option was entirely voluntary for the period prior to 2019. Forcing the appellant to adopt this ratio retrospectively was patently erroneous. Furthermore, because the new tax structure did not exist during the contested period, the Revenue had no legal basis to accuse the appellant of fraud or suppression of facts to invoke the extended period of limitation.
Ultimately, the Court passed the order setting aside the massive tax and penalty demands issued by the CGST authorities, providing immense relief to the renewable energy sector.

 

Read the Judgment here.

Categories

Categories

Related Articles

Have questions on this topic or a
related matter?

Our team is available to provide structured, practical guidance.

DISCLAIMER

The Bar Council of India prohibits lawyers and law firms from soliciting work and advertising in any form or manner. By accessing this website, you acknowledge that you are seeking information about Curare Legal, on your own accord without solicitation, advertisement, or inducement from us or our members. This website provides general information for reference purposes only, and we make no promises or guarantees regarding its accuracy, completeness, or reliability. The website’s contents are not intended to constitute legal advice or solicitation and should not be construed as such. By using this website, you agree that the information and materials are for your general information only and do not establish an attorney-client relationship or provide legal advice. All content and materials on this website are the intellectual property of Curare Legal and shall not be used without our express prior written consent.